A blanket ban is a visibility decision. Block the domain, and the same files move to a personal account on a network you do not monitor. Inventory first, then decide tool by tool.
- Sanction it when people depend on it and the risk is acceptable. Name an owner. Put it behind single sign-on where the vendor supports it. If company data will live there, put a contract and data terms in place before you call it approved.
- Limit it when the work is low risk. Say which data must not go in, who is responsible, and when you will look again. A tolerated tool with a named owner is manageable. The same tool with no owner is still shadow IT.
- Stop it when the data or the vendor is outside what you can accept. Block or replace it, and hand people the approved tool in the same step. A ban with no replacement sends the work to a personal account.
Make the approved path faster than a trial. Shadow IT grows where asking for a tool takes longer than starting one. A short intake — what the tool is, what data it will hold, and who owns it — is the practical control.
Where the shadow tool duplicates a product you already pay for, keep one. If you keep the approved product, move the work back and cancel the extra subscription, then see who never returned to those seats. If the shadow tool is the one people use, sanction that one and cut the idle seats on the old contract.
Check again on a schedule. New trials and new AI tools show up between audits. SSO grants, card reports, and a short survey catch the next wave. One cleanup does not stay current.